They have a great selection of sports memorabilia and cards. Along with very attentive and knowledgeable owners. Throw in some live autograph signing opportunities even makes it that much better. It is our #1 card shop!
Baseball Card Castle
Owner claimed
Baseball Card Castle is a sports card shop in Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania. They specialize in sports cards.
A local home for collectors.
20+ million organized cards and 100,000+ autographed items; named in Reddit road-trip threads and Topps' 2026 Pittsburgh guide.
Photos
Reviews from Google
4.7 · 210 reviews See all reviews on Google
The best place I’ve been to for cards and memorabilia. Well organized and the owner was very friendly and helpful. Went in for some Konnor Griffin and Paul Skenes cards. Also came out with an awesome Mark McGwire figurine statue and signed ball!
Stores fine. I would have given 5 stars but sold some cards to them and researched afterwards what card shops normally pay they were way below so much that it left me feeling a bit ripped off. Offered 50 dollars for over 200 in cards and good easily sellable cards. That said the owner is nice and patient with collectors and the store has good variety. But after supporting them since 91 I feel conflicted that they would offer such poor prices, it was predatory.
The best card shop in Western Pennsylvania, by far. Jeff, the owner, is the most knowledgeable man in the business. He is fair and honest, hard qualities to find in the sports card game. I highly recommend this shop to all collectors, no matter their experience or wallet size.
The owner was very knowledgeable and patient with my 8 year old son who asked a lot of questions today. He helped us with our selections and my son can’t wait to come back! He was very fair and generous with his prices. Great experience!
On Google Maps
Upcoming events
Details
20555 U.S. 19
Cranberry Township, PA 16066