An amazing card shop! Definitely my favorite spot! Bought some sweet cards here. My favorite find so far was a John Stockton Rookie Card! They have a great mix of modern and retro cards. I definitely know they have basketball (my favorite), baseball, and football. Pretty sure they have hockey too, just haven’t checked out the display yet. If you like cards, you got to check this place out.
American Legends
American Legends is a trading card shop in Scarsdale, New York.
A local home for collectors.
American Legends is a trading card shop in Scarsdale, New York.
Photos
Reviews from Google
4.3 · 128 reviews See all reviews on Google
I can't say enough about what a great store this is. The owners are some of the nicest people you will ever meet. They are one of the rare ones that have been around the hobby forever and has been able to evolve to what it has become. A beautiful store and a great group of people running it.
I've driven past this place for years and went in for the first time today. I was immediately welcomed with warm energy and received very honest/professional advice regarding a card set we own. I ended up purchasing my first pack (2025-26 Topps Chrome®) since I was a kid. I will definitely return.
In a world where most owners can’t be bothered while they try and get 2-3x the market on their cards, it’s nice to walk into a store that has quality products, an assortment of sports at varying prices and to see them priced actually at the market! Shocking! Only been to 4 stores in the area but this one would be the top by far.
This is a beautifully designed space with gems of unique and fundamental important NY Sports scene tied memorabilia. Great inventory of sports cards and Pokemon - but the thing that truly separates this place from the others is Andrew, Max, Alex and the Team. It’s just a different vibe and experience one of great energy, cooperation and enjoyment. 10 of 5 stars…keep up the great work fellas - thank you
On Google Maps
Upcoming events
Details
Scarsdale, NY